Many of my clients love to put testimonials on their web pages.
There’s nothing wrong with testimonials, mind you, but they’re simply not as effective as case studies in web marketing.
Here’s why I like case studies…
Take this testimonial:
“The people at Best Mart went over the top to help me avoid wasting my money on an inferior product. They are some of the most knowledgeable people I’ve ever talked to about dog kennels.”
That’s a perfectly fine testimonial that gives you an idea about how friendly, warm, helpful, and knowledgeable the people at Best Mart are.
However, as a visitor to the website, there’s nothing in that testimonial to catch my attention, draw me into a conversation, or help me withmy problem.
In other words, there is no inherent value for me in the testimonial.
It helps if my decision to buy from Best Mart or their competitor comes down these factors. But, even then, there’s probably not much chance that I’m going to even read the testimonial on the web page.
Testimonials are often like white noise on web pages. They make for great fillers to break up long copy on a page, but they’re mostly skipped over.
Think about it…
Do you read the testimonials on a page?
There are two really good solutions to this love/hate relationship I have with testimonials:
1. Convert your static website into a blog; and…
2. Use case studies instead of testimonials.
Since this post is mostly about case studies, I’ll just touch on the first point.
See, with a blog, you can disseminate helpful information about your products or services – information that adds value to the experience of your customers.
You can do the same thing with a Facebook page, but blogs give you far more control over what gets posted by your visitors.
Then, you encourage your customers to comment on your blog posts. If they make a positive comment about your product or service in a blog post, it holds far more value and credibility than the same statement inserted as a “testimonial” on a web page.
Now, on to case studies.
What is a Case Study?
The primary difference between a case study and a testimonial is that a case study provides some helpful information to the reader.
If, for example, I’m looking for a new dog kennel, and I run across a case study on Best Mart website that sounds just like my situation, I’m going to come away having learned something of value … and I’ll be much more likely to buy the kennel from Best Mart.
Let’s see if we can create a case study from our original testimonial…
Jane Doe called us with a dilemma we hear all too often: she was confused by the dozens of different dog kennels that were available and couldn’t decide which would be best for her and her pet.
We asked about her dog – breed, temperament, age, etc. After 25 years of selling dog kennels, we’ve found that certain brands, such as “Extreme Kennels” work much better for hyperactive dogs, while other brands like “Cozy Home” are best for the mellow breeds of dogs.
Jane explained that her dog was 13 years old, and while still active, she’s sleeping far more than she has in the past. For Jane and her dog, we recommended the “Safe Slumber” kennel because it’s designed specifically for older dogs who still like to move and play occasionally.
Jane, as you might expect was quite excited about her purchase, and relayed to us later how pleased she was with our assistance. We believe that if you and your dog aren’t happy, then we’re not happy.
I admit that I don’t have one iota of knowledge about dogs or dog kennels, so please excuse my inaccuracies (and references to brands, just in case the above brands actually exist!)
Still … the point is that upon reading the case study, the website visitor will have learned at least one thing of value, and in so doing, feels “obligated” on some level to “repay” the kindess.
This is what is called the “Law of Reciprocity,” or “Reciprocation” in social science.
The visitor feels emotionally obligated to repay the gesture, and will reciprocate by either adding a comment on the blog post, buying a product from the company, or even thanking them via an email.
Every time you provide something of value, as perceived by your website visitor, you’re putting a quarter in the “reciprocity” meter.
At some point, they’ll feel an obligation or commitment to give back.
And, you can bank on that.




“They’re coming to the site, but nobody is signing up or buying…”